***Please take out a membership to support the light of truth.***
“Anybody who has managed to read the book already knows that it ends basically on a cliffhanger ending - what’s going to happen at the midterms if they happen at all. So the good news is they did happen… there was something of a rebuke to the Republicans… it is still premature to say that we’re out of the woods.. It is still a dangerous situation for democracy.”—Keir Giles from Bette Dangerous Podcast, Ep99
In Part 2 of our Bette’s Book Club meeting with American Overthrow author Keir Giles, we focus on the hard and dangerous work ahead.
Here is information about his new book, which was released this week in America.
Below are some excerpted highlights from the transcript of our interview, lightly edited for brevity and clarity:
Keir: Anybody who has managed to read the book already knows that it ends basically on a cliffhanger ending - what’s going to happen at the midterms if they happen at all. So the good news is they did happen. The further good news is that there was something of a rebuke to the Republicans in the voting figures.
Unfortunately, that is as far as we got at the moment. So we know that the program that was underway to try to get control of the electoral system and of the voting process did not succeed partly because of the resistance of lower level courts that simply said this is not how elections in the United States work and no you’re not going to take control of all of these voter rolls and control of the voting system.
So they didn’t get as far along as they had hoped. What we don’t know yet is what is going to be the response by the Trump group because they seem still to be formulating their response and haven’t actually yet come back with anything beyond firing off a couple of truth social posts about the voting being fraudulent. So how they react to it I think is going to still playout over the next days and weeks and that of course is the other part of the equation. Plus, of course, they’ve still got another two years to do what they can before the presidential elections, and then we might be facing the same challenge. So it is encouraging.
And the worst case outcome that I describe at the very end of the book hasn’t happened yet. But I think it is still premature to say that we’re out of the woods and we’re all OK. It is still a dangerous situation for democracy.
Heidi: Yes, thank you so much… I see this as a long and scary haul… it is worth taking a moment to celebrate… but it’s what we do the next day and the day after that. And Let’s just rewind a bit because, again, when I read your book and I was continually reminded of things that I think I either wanted to forget or I didn’t quite have the capacity to remember, because there is a daily onslaught. And so let’s strip away the euphoria right now, strip away any hopium and just in broad strokes remind us of what this regime has been doing in the last two years that is going to be hard, if not impossible in some aspects to reverse. Please just give us the brass tacks.
Keir: Yeah, it is hard to keep up. It’s hard to keep track of just how much has transformed when there’s this deluge every day and all of the news keeps tumbling over each other. So that’s, I think, one of the things that surprised me. When you bring it all together, 18 months’ worth and condense it into one place and write about what’s changed in a book, then the enormity of what has actually transformed becomes far more clear. And some of those changes I see, I think are probably irreversible. It might be possible under a future administration to depoliticize the Department of Justice to make it not be an implement that the leadership group can use to punish its enemies. But it won’t be easy. It might be possible to disband ICE and to step away from a situation where the United States has roving federal paramilitary masked security gangs that can murder people with impunity.
But these things tend not to go quietly. It might be possible to step back from the deportation program of deportations. And in my business, when you hear the word deportations, you think of exiling and enslaving thousands of captive populations to Siberia, but now you have a situation in the United States where you have gangs going in with targeted arrest quotas in exactly the same way as the NKVD did in Stalin’s Russia to round up people, gathering up the innocent together with the guilty, ship them out of the reach of the rule of law and then potentially deport them to a third country they had no connection with.
So that is something which is also going to be difficult to undo. But then, there are things we already know cannot be done. And that’s not just the international relationships where the United States was treated as the hub of the systems of alliances and partnerships and trading relationships that it created, which it’s now largely undone, the trust which that depended on, but also things closer to home, like the health problems that are arising in the United States as a result, for example, of canceling vaccination programs, canceling food safety programs. Diseases that people thought had been eradicated are now roaring back across parts of the United States.
Same with food borne illnesses. If you don’t check for them and you don’t count how many are happening, then don’t be surprised if many people get ill from eating lettuce.
So all of these different things… the environment, for example, the changes to forestry laws that have already been acted on by Trump’s oligarch buddies, the changes to clean air, to safe drinking water, all the fire axe that’s been taken to regulations. That’s something which was hard won over decades, it has been demolished in a course of months and would be very, very difficult to put back.
When people ask me just how much has changed, I always come back to that one illustration of what happened in Minneapolis in January of this year, which I think we might have talked about the last time because it’s such a stark illustration of how far we’ve come.
If you think of the club of countries around the world where you can be detained by masked paramilitaries on the streets and they demand your papers and if they don’t like the answer, they can take you away. But also it turns out that if they really don’t like the answer, they can shoot you and then there’s no consequence for them whatsoever. They have absolute immunity. That puts the United States in a very, very small club of nations around the world and they are all deeply, deeply nasty ones. And that, of course, is an indication of just how far things have come…
I’m still waiting for somebody to tell me that everything in the book is wrong and the conclusions it reaches are incorrect and that the evidence that is - there’s a huge great thick bibliography at the back because I wanted people to be able to check for themselves about the mad things that I was saying to read back for themselves and see the original source, watch the original video of Trump or somebody around him saying these mad things - in the hope that somebody could prove me wrong.
I sent the draft, not just to you, but also to diehard Trumpists, to friends and colleagues who are either in the first Trump administration or I know still approve of what is being done and think it’s good for the United States, asking them, what do you think of this? What’s your reaction when you read all of this?
The way in which they responded was absolutely unanimous. It was absolutely fascinating. It wasn’t abuse. It wasn’t trying to argue with me. It wasn’t trying to disprove anything. It was complete silence, total silence, no response whatsoever, which means that, like me, they just never read their emails, or they couldn’t disagree with what was in it.
Also, they couldn’t agree with what was in it because, you know, that’s a brave political choice to write something like that down in email under the current political system where you never know when those emails are going to be uncovered. But they couldn’t say, ‘no, it’s wrong.’
And that is very disturbing. It still hasn’t happened. And the book has been out for, what, about a month and a half in the U.K.
Heidi: And when you see Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff repeatedly going to Moscow, and again, as somebody who has watched how Russia does things for a very long time, what goes through your head or helps us understand what we’re seeing?
Keir: I’m getting a bit of a headache from all the face-palming. There are two explanations that people are putting forward for what Witkoff and Kushner are doing. One is they have absolutely no idea what they’re doing, and therefore they are a blank canvas on which Russia can design whatever it wants the outcome to be, and they will then transmit that outcome, as they have been doing, to Ukraine and to Europe, saying these are Russia’s demands that have to be met. Without actually recognizing what the implications of that are and how it is actually not even possible, even if anybody wanted to meet it, to do these things.
The other explanation, and this is even worse, is that they do know exactly what they’re doing and they are simply working on behalf of Moscow to get the Ukraine war settled as rapidly as possible, to put the Europeans... make them silent as rapidly as possible in order that they can work with Moscow to chase these mythical profits they’ve been promised.
So it’s hard to say which of those is actually the worst, possibly the second one.
Heidi: (Regarding the midterms) Did you think there was some thought that there was an anticipation that it was going to be a deluge and that they wouldn’t be able to noodle the margins? I’m just confused that they built this election denial industrial complex and then have not used it…
Keir: I think it’s still delayed reaction because we haven’t seen the full response yet. And I think part of that might be the other thing that we could discern immediately after the results started coming in was surprise, was shock on the part of MAGA and the Republican Party and Trump himself personally because they weren’t expecting this.
I think it seems that they fell into the trap once again of believing their own propaganda and thinking they might not have to fix the election because everybody still loves what they do and supports them. So the extent of the setback may have been something that they were startled by and therefore not prepared to deal with.
And that’s why we need to watch over the next few days and weeks what that longer-term response is going to be once they’ve got their act together and got a plan.
Heidi: One of the things I finally realized reading your book is that if you are part of Trump’s inner circle or his orbit, and you’re willing to debase yourself and your family, you stand to make a lot of money. And in your book, you documented the corruption with a capital C, all the money that was being made pretty much openly. Fig leaves removed. And for me, I find it very difficult to believe that people who have earned or gifted such enormous sums by playing along with Trump, would literally just say, ‘oh, well, I guess we’re not liked.’ I just find it difficult to believe that people would just walk away from that amount of money-making grift, because it’s documented in many cases as being criminal. So how do you walk away from something like that?
Keir: Especially when it’s documented as being criminal, but there doesn’t appear to be any consequences. And that’s one of the ways I write about that the Trump group is not just emulating Russia, but actually surpassing Russia, because Russia pretends to be a democracy. It pretends it’s not corrupt. It pretends that the rule of law is in place, whereas Trump doesn’t feel the need for pretense. Because it turns out the system has no protection against people like Trump to step in and milk it for all they’re worth. And I think it’s on the back of that Maggie Haberman book, Regime Change, one of the classic Trump quotes: “I found out nobody cared, and I was allowed to, so I did,” which is exactly what’s happened. No safeguards, no guardrails. Because the system was set up under the assumption that the people who arrived in positions of power like that would be public-spirited individuals with a certain amount of integrity and decency. And it’s not protected against people who have none.”
Heidi: Do you have any idea, having written multiple books on this subject, both documenting Russia and documenting MAGA America - I don’t understand people like Sean Duffy and Markwayne Mullen and Kristi Noem and any of the blondes who have been his press secretaries. I don’t understand it - I know there’s a lot of money to be made but I do not understand how you remove any integrity or decency or any shred of it in order just to get up and just be part of this giant lie factory. I find it really tragic and sad.
Keir: Yeah, well, everybody will have their own particular reasons for being there, whether it is that they prioritize money making over everything else or prioritize being close to power or it satisfies their own bloated egos, whatever it might be. They’ve made that deal with themselves. If they had any conscience in the first place, they’ve decided that that is not the most important thing in their lives. And that’s the result.
Heidi: Wow. OK, one last thing for me, one or two more things. You write about the war on facts and truth, media control and consolidation. And this is something that is deeply and profoundly concerning because despite this consolidation we’ve seen, despite the Trump friendly purchases of major media outlets, we still had people who voted in numbers that we haven’t seen in some time to say, ‘we don’t want this.’ And again, maybe it’s the reality hitting home of high gas prices. I think it was you who said when things get bad enough for people, that’s when maybe, you know, you see them actually step up. But what do we do about the war on facts and truth? For example, on Friday, I’m watching the news feed obsessively because I’m trying to figure out what’s happening. I have been waiting for Trump to do something awful. And as I’ve said, you know, partake in some sort of destructive thing and blame it on Antifa.
Like I’ve been anticipating some kind of horrific black swan event, and I’m seeing what’s happening that all planes are grounded. We haven’t seen anything like that since 9-11. But one thing I know is, we can’t count on getting the truth from any of these people. So what do we do about the war on facts and truth? How can we somehow rise above it? Other than reading your books and other recommended writers, what do we do?
Keir: Well, again, it depends a lot on who we are…
Heidi: Pro-democracy.
Keir: Because by definition, we here are the people who take an interest in these things and who want to find out and who are interested in what’s happening to their country. But that is not necessarily the broad mass of individuals. So it is possible, even after all of the media changes and the consolidation in the United States go through, even after other media outlets have gone the way of CBS and become essentially the mouthpieces of the regime, you will still be able to find out news and information about what is happening. It just takes more effort.
And that’s exactly the same as the situation in Russia. It’s still possible, but you need to be motivated to actually go and invest the effort in finding out those sources of information. And that’s why we have the resurgence of these words like samizdat and tamizdat, which was in Soviet times, samizdat, self-publishing, tamizdat, publishing over there.
In other words, it’s something that would be imported into the country probably illegally because it’s a source of news and information and ideas. That is not in accordance with what the regime wants you to see. We had an example of that very, very early on in the takeover of CBS, for example, which I managed to put in the book. The way the documentary on CECOT, the El Salvadorian prison where people were being sent to, was suppressed by the new CBS head, installed as part of this takeover, but it still aired in Canada. So anybody that could import it from Canada, whether electronically or watch it across the border, was still getting the news beamed into them from outside in exactly the way that previously the United States would send information outwards into authoritarian regimes. So again, it’s a measure of how the roles have reversed, that now it’s the covert, the subversive transmission of information that is informing Americans.
Heidi: I wrote my Hot Type column this weekend on how I believe that Democrats should first and foremost work to sever the U.S.-Russia alliance that Trump has gone all in on as a first step to fixing some of this. And I wrote in my headline, ‘Wiill the U.S. Democrats take on the Russia problem?’ And I’m going to turn that question over to you. I have worked on multiple campaigns… And I have not seen any indication, over all, that Democrats would be willing to take on the Russia problem. Under Biden, I wrote op-eds and speeches and begged him to address it, because you taught me a long time ago, when a leader stands up and says, ‘We are a target nation of this type of warfare, this information warfare, and we need you to know about it, we’re going to dedicate resources to fighting it,’ then that can actually help get people prepared for it. Many countries do this, and they are much further ahead. And I’m actually very happy to know that the UK is actually creating a department in the UK, and that Russia was involved in Brexit. I realize it’s 10 years later, but it’s something. So with their newfound strength, should they take on the Russia problem? And will they? How do you see it?
Keir: Well, it depends on which Russia problem. If we’re talking about the problem of Russian political subversion, then it is extremely hard now to restart all of the different ways in which the United States was looking into Russian influence on its politics. Partly because we’ve already seen the attitude to that of the Trump group. They will shut down anything that gets even close to looking at Russia’s influence on American politics, purge the individuals involved, and lie about the intelligence findings. So where do you start with that? If you have an intelligence community, a counterintelligence system that is already firmly in the grip of the regime, you’re not going to be able to trigger investigations that would actually discredit that regime. So all of that will have to wait until possibly, in some not too close future, there is not just control of Congress, but also control of the levers of power that drive the national security establishment.
Because the only alternative at the moment is doing it all from outside the government. And of course, plenty of people have. Plenty of people have written great thick books about why exactly Trump is so beholden to Putin. But that is not the same as impact within the system to demonstrate that you’re dealing with an active counterintelligence threat sitting in the Oval Office.
Heidi: Everybody here will be reminded that we had intelligence agencies and agents under Biden tell us about the influencers and reporters who were reporting on America, seemingly from a conservative point of view, who were actually financed through cutouts related to RT…
Would there be any benefit to the Democrats holding congressional hearings just to air all this in front of people? ‘Here’s Trump, here’s his ties,’ just to shame him in front of the American people. Is there any point to doing that?
Keir: Well, whether it benefits or not, it ought to be done. The problem is two-fold. First of all, who are you going to draw in? Because they will need some pretty solid promises of protection from the regime, before they’ll stand up and testify like that. You take some very, very brave individuals, of which there are some, but possibly not enough. We see them standing up and holding to the truth, despite all the intimidation that’s thrown at them. Second problem, of course, is the preemptive discrediting that the Trump group has already undertaken, that everything is a Russia, Russia, Russia hoax, and some people will already be believing that. So when they see other political forces in the country dragging this up again and returning to the idea that Trump is an agent of and consciously or unconsciously working for Moscow, they will automatically pigeonhole it in that box and say, ‘well, this proves that Trump was correct. They just will not let go of the Russia thing.’
Heidi: I will not let go of the Russia thing. Just FYI, I will not let go of it, because I’m big mad still. I’m with Marci Shore. My goal in life now is just to keep fascism in remission. That is going to be my goal. It never seems to go away, but let’s keep it in remission for another 80 years. So Keir, thank you so much.
Interestingly, the Wall Street Journal editorial board, which spent a decade touting the ‘Russia hoax’ came out yesterday and stated: "It’s increasingly hard to resist the conclusion that Mr. Trump’s real goal is to appease Mr. Putin."
As my noted by my friend Simon Nixon - who writes the brilliant Wealth of Nations substack - they owe the world an apology.
Have a listen to this Bette Dangerous Podcast and thank you to everyone for your support always.
More about Keir Giles and American Overthrow:
KEIR GILES has advised governments worldwide on the Russian threat. A former senior fellow with Chatham House’s Russia and Eurasia Programme, he regularly comments for the BBC and international media. His prescient books include Who Will Defend Europe?, a Financial Times Politics Book of the Year.
More about American Overthrow:
AMERICAN OVERTHROW — HAS RUSSIA BROUGHT ABOUT REGIME CHANGE IN THE USA? The maelstrom following Donald Trump’s 2025 return to the US presidency left many bemused and disoriented. But for Russia-watchers, what unfolded was grimly familiar. So many of the Trump administration’s destructive actions have precisely aligned with the Kremlin’s own objectives; and to a startling extent, Trump’s America is beginning to mimic Russia itself.
Abroad, Trump has demanded the annexation of neighbours, and embraced war crimes in Iran and the Caribbean. At home, the war on truth and history, purges and the weaponisation of justice, the deployment of masked federal paramilitaries to the streets of major cities and more all mirror Vladimir Putin’s own consolidation of power. Dismantling obstacles to Russia’s ambitions, whether they threaten Europe or America itself, is a defining feature of Trump’s second presidency. And just like Putin, Trump shows no intention of departing at the end of his presidential term. Keir Giles examines America’s transformation through the prism of Kremlinology. What he reveals should alarm us all.
Quotes on American Overthrow:
‘Keir Giles draws direct parallels between the Trump oligarchy’s consolidation of power in the United States and Vladimir Putin’s rule in Russia. This is not a bizarre or far-fetched comparison, and it should make readers of all political persuasions think twice about American politics.’—ANNE APPLEBAUM, author of Autocracy, Inc.
‘As Keir Giles makes abundantly clear in this expertly written and insightful book, Donald Trump’s political template is Vladimir Putin’s.’—FIONA HILL, former US National Security Council advisor
‘Giles highlights Kremlin method in Trump’s madness. A must-read.’—EDWARD LUCAS, former senior editor, The Economist
‘A meticulous forensic examination of how the Trump administration’s objectives precisely match those of the Kremlin.’—TOOMAS HENDRIK ILVES, former president of Estonia
‘For the last decade, I’ve chronicled how Moscow cultivated Donald Trump as an intelligence asset. In American Overthrow, Keir Giles—a Russia specialist at Chatham House—takes that story into the second Trump administration, where the payoff for Russia is finally revealed.
By assembling the scattered scandals of the Trump era into a single, coherent, and chilling whole, Giles does what the daily flood of headlines cannot: he shows how Trump doesn’t merely emulate Russia but often outdoes it—creating his own set of “alternative facts,” activating masked paramilitaries, threatening neighboring allies, and consolidating power in the hands of his billionaire friends.
The picture that emerges—a fractured Europe, a hobbled NATO, a White House at war with its own intelligence agencies—amounts to dividends beyond Putin’s wildest dreams. This is the rare book that says exactly what has happened: Russia has effected regime change in the United States with the active support of millions of Americans—and most of them still don’t even know it.’—CRAIG UNGER, author of House of Trump, House of Putin and American Kompromat.
To pre-order American Overthrow (Hurst Publishers), follow this link or click this button:
To order outside of Amazon, the book is also available from Bookshop:
American Overthrow worldwide publishing dates:
September 3, UK and Europe
November 15; Available for purchase October 15, US
****
****
Bette Dangerous is a reader-funded magazine. Thank you to all monthly, annual, and founding members.
I expose the corruption of billionaire fascists with support from your memberships.
Thank you in advance for considering the following:
Share my reporting with your networks
Buying my ebooks
A private link to an annual membership discount for older adults, those on fixed incomes or drawing disability, as well as activists and members of the media is available upon request at bettedangerous/gmail. 🥹
More info about Bette Dangerous: This magazine is written by Heidi Siegmund Cuda, an Emmy-award winning investigative reporter, author, and broadcast news veteran, as well as former music and nightlife columnist for the Los Angeles Times. A No. 1 Amazon best-selling author and award-winning film director, Cuda writes the Hot Type column in Byline Times, an independent UK-newspaper. She executive produced the film Kherson: Human Safari. Thank you for your support of independent investigative journalism, arts, and culture reporting.
🤍
Begin each day with a grateful heart.
🤍










